Allometric
scaling of knee extension strength in youths: Examination of gender differences
Joseph P. Weir1, T.J. Housh2,
D.J. Housh3, G.O. Johnson2,
K.T. Ebersole2, and S.R. Perry2
1Program in Physical Therapy,
University of Osteopathic Medicine & Health Sciences, Des Moines, IA,
2Department of Health & Human Performance, University of
Nebraska, Lincoln, NE, 3Department of Oral Biology, College
of Dentistry, University of Nebraska Medical Center, Lincoln, NE
Objective. In youths, muscle strength has been shown to exhibit
an age effect, in which increases in age are associated with increases
in strength independent of differences in body size. To date, the effect
of gender on the age effect has not been examined. In this study, we examined
age effects for isokinetic strength between genders using multivariate
allometric scaling to control for differences in body size.
Participants. The subjects were 72 competitive female gymnasts (mean
age ± SD = 15.7 ± 1.2 years) and 150 male high school wrestlers
(mean age ± SD = 16.6 ± 1.0 years).
Measures. The subjects were tested for isokinetic knee extension
peak torque at 30, 180, and 300 degrees/sec. The body size variable was
fat-free weight (FFW) determined with hydrostatic weighing. The allometric
analyses were performed using multiple regression. The dependent variables
were log of isokinetic torque (one each for each velocity) and the independent
variables were log of FFW, log of age, and log of gender (gender dummy
codes: 2 = female, 3 = male).
Results. the analyses showed significant main effects for FFW, ange,
and gender. There were no significant interactions, indicating that common
scaling exponents for age and FFw were appropriate for both genders. All
FFW scaling exponents included 1.0 in the 95% confidence intervals, indicating
a response consistent with dimensionality theory, which suggests that muscle
torque should scale to mass to the 1.0 power. The significant main effects
for age indicated that, after accounting for differences in body size,
older subjects exhibited greater peak torque. The significant sex effects
indicated that, after controlling for FFW and age, male subjects on average
had higher peak torque than the females. The FFW and age corrected gender
differences were 14.9, 16.7 and 13.6% at 30, 180, and 300 degrees/sec,
respectively.
Conclusions. These results indicate that: 1) the age effect is similar
for males and females (non-significant interactions), and 2) even after
correcting for differences in FFW and age, males were stronger than the
females. The causes of the gender differences require further study.